Can police stop someone and pat them down just because an officer believes they might be carrying a firearm? As far as I’m concerned, the answer is “no,” and it’s not a tough call to make. Bearing arms is a constitutionally protected right. Suspicion that someone may be carrying a gun doesn’t mean that police can just assume they’re doing so illegally.
The Maryland Supreme Court is considering this issue in a case called Hunter v. Maryland, and Stephen Hunter has drawn an unlikely ally in his attempt to overturn a lower court decision to deny his motion to suppress evidence after an officer stopped and frisked him based on an alleged belief that he had a firearm in his pocket.
The Legal Defense Fund, which filed an amicus brief in Bruen that defended New York’s “may issue” concealed carry licensing regime, has now filed an amicus brief in Hunter v. Maryland that argues gun possession, in and of itself, is not a crime, and officers must have a reasonable suspicion of criminal activity before conducting a stop.
I wish I could say that the Legal Defense Fund has seen the error of its past ways, but after reading its latest amicus brief it’s clear that the LDF’s argument in Hunter is based on expediency, not any sort of intellectual evolution about the right to keep and bear arms. The group makes that quite clear in a footnote.
LDF submitted an amicus brief in Bruen, which argued that the Second Amendment reserves, for the states, the power to impose reasonable limitations on firearm possession outside the home. LDF continues to maintain that this is the correct interpretation of the Second Amendment; nevertheless, as long as Bruen remains controlling law, its consequences must be fairly and consistently applied and considered when determining the bounds of the Fourth Amendment.
After a relatively deep dive into the civil rights movement, the Second Amendment activities of some civil rights activists, and the Jim Crow gun laws that deprived many blacks from being able to defend themselves and their loved ones from targeted violence, I cannot for the life of me understand why LDF would be opposed to a robust right to keep and bear arms.
Regardless, the organization’s attorneys at least recognize that Bruen is valid law. And taken with other cases like Terry v. Ohio, which held that stopping and frisking someone doesn’t violate the Fourth Amendment so long as there’s specific, articulable facts that give an officer reasonable belief that criminal activity is taking place, it should be pretty clear to courts across the country that police can’t stop an adult just because they think they might be carrying a gun.
In fact, the Maryland appellate court seems to have recognized that in a case decided earlier this year called Hicks v. State. Steven Hicks was sentenced to five years for illegally carrying a firearm, but the appellate court reversed that conviction after determining that there was no legitimate reason for police to have stopped him.
Although the Maryland appellate courts have, for decades, upheld police stops based on reasonable suspicion that a person is in possession of a gun, after Bruen, carrying a handgun publicly for self-defense is presumptively lawful, and therefore, mere possession of a concealed firearm, by itself, is not indicative of criminal activity. The mere possibility that a person with a gun might not have a valid license or otherwise may be restricted from possessing a gun is not enough to establish reasonable suspicion for a seizure. The police must have reasonable suspicion that the person is possessing the gun illegally or otherwise engaged in criminal activity. Because the officers here stopped appellant based solely on his possession of a gun, without reasonable suspicion that he was possessing the gun illegally or otherwise involved in criminal activity, they did not have reasonable suspicion to stop him.
The appellate court went on to note that if a legal stop is made, “officers may frisk a suspect carrying a gun regardless of whether the suspect is carrying the gun legally or illegally” because a firearm is a dangerous weapon. The key, though, is that the stop itself has to be based on reasonable suspicion of criminal activity. A constitutional right isn’t much of a right if exercising it automatically gives the government grounds to investigate you.
The LDF says in its amicus brief that “the record does not contain any evidence that officers had a credible suspicion that Mr. Hunter lacked a lawful permit to possess a handgun when he was stopped,” and argues “that lack of evidence should end the inquiry as to whether the stop for suspicion of gun possession without a permit violates the Fourth Amendment.” But the LDF also points out that police can try to get around the “reasonable suspicion” requirement by pointing to “furtive movements,” a presence in a “high-crime area,” and holding a hand “in proximity to [the] waistband.”
The amorphous character of boilerplate justifications, and the frequency with which they are cited to claim a person is armed, render them insufficiently particularized as bases for a Terry stop. If identical justifications apply to stops made under an enormous variety of different circumstances, the “suspicion” those justifications ostensibly provide becomes general, not particularized. For example, in an effort to determine the frequency with which police officers cited identical justifications as the bases for their stops, professors Jeffrey Fagan and Amanda Geller analyzed over four million NYPD stop reports generated during an eight-year period. The professors found that officers often recycled the same justifications across time and geographic area: “proximity to scene” appeared in 20.1% of the reports, “changed direction” appeared in 24% of reports, and “area has high crime incidence” appeared in 56% of reports. In other words, more than half of the stops NYPD officers documented over the course of eight years were based on the exact same justification—and one that has nothing to do with the conduct of the person being stopped at that. That is not particularized suspicion, and without more, it is not constitutional.
I think the LDF was and is wrong about Bruen, and I wish that the group would recognize the inherent importance of our Second Amendment rights beyond the amendment’s utility in a particular legal argument.
Still, I think they’re right about the unconstitutional nature of stopping someone simply on the suspicion that they might be carrying a gun. The right to bear arms can’t be treated as probable cause for a police encounter, and exercising that right shouldn’t require proving your innocence to an officer on the street. If the Legal Defense Fund can recognize that principle despite its opposition to Bruen, there’s no reason the Maryland Supreme Court shouldn’t recognize it too.
Editor’s Note: The radical Left will stop at nothing to enact their extreme gun control agenda and strip us of our Second Amendment rights.
Help us continue to report on and expose the Democrats’ gun-grabbing schemes. Join Bearing Arms VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
Read the full article here
45 Comments
If AISC keeps dropping, this becomes investable for me.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Nice to see insider buying—usually a good signal in this space.
If AISC keeps dropping, this becomes investable for me.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Nice to see insider buying—usually a good signal in this space.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Uranium names keep pushing higher—supply still tight into 2026.
The cost guidance is better than expected. If they deliver, the stock could rerate.
Exploration results look promising, but permitting will be the key risk.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Exploration results look promising, but permitting will be the key risk.
Production mix shifting toward USA might help margins if metals stay firm.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Exploration results look promising, but permitting will be the key risk.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
I like the balance sheet here—less leverage than peers.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
The cost guidance is better than expected. If they deliver, the stock could rerate.
Production mix shifting toward USA might help margins if metals stay firm.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Production mix shifting toward USA might help margins if metals stay firm.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Production mix shifting toward USA might help margins if metals stay firm.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Nice to see insider buying—usually a good signal in this space.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
If AISC keeps dropping, this becomes investable for me.
I like the balance sheet here—less leverage than peers.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
If AISC keeps dropping, this becomes investable for me.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Uranium names keep pushing higher—supply still tight into 2026.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Production mix shifting toward USA might help margins if metals stay firm.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.