Judge Dismisses Murder Charge, Rules Woman Acted to Defend Herself Against Ex

An Ohio judge has cleared a woman who was facing murder charges in the death of her ex-girlfriend, ruling that the shooting was a justifiable use of force allowed under state law. 

There was never any question that 26-year-old Marshee Luther shot and killed 29-year-old Taralynn Bowers last August. The dispute between prosecutors and Luther’s defense team was whether or not Luther had a reasonable belief that her life was in danger when she drew her gun and pulled the trigger. 

In fact, the prosecutors came awfully close to admitting that Luther’s life was in danger that day, though they argued that there was no way Luther could have known that. 

The couple started dating in December 2024 and broke up a few months later in March 2025.

On the day of the shooting, Bowers was invited to another woman’s home to talk about the breakup, Assistant Hamilton County Prosecutor Joe Otero said in court. The situation grew emotional after Luther arrived, he said, although it was calm by the time both women went their separate ways.

Bowers left the home but returned uninvited less than an hour later, now calling for Luther to come outside to fight, according to trial testimony.

Luther told police she didn’t want to fight and was sitting on the couch when Bowers came inside toward her and reached into a cross-body purse. She perceived the movement as a threat, stood up and pulled the trigger.

The only item found in Bowers’ purse was a foldable pocket knife.

“The knife is a hindsight fact,” Otero said in court. “But we’re not dealing with hindsight … we’re dealing with what came about in that moment.”

Bowers had also sent texts to the third woman when she was on her way back to the home, telling her that “she’s [Luther] gonna die,” but Luther had no knowledge of that threat at the time, so prosecutors deemed the text irrelevant. 

What Luther did have, though was experience in dealing with her ex beforehand. 

Court records show that Bowers was charged with burglary in April 2025, accused of breaking into Luther’s home through a window and stealing two doorbell cameras. The charge was later dropped after Luther failed to follow through with the prosecution, according to testimony.

Fox said there were previous unreported instances in which Bowers threatened Luther with a gun and, in one alleged incident on the day of their breakup, slashed the woman’s wrist with a butcher’s knife.

“She cut me because I told her I didn’t want to be with her,” Luther said in the interview. She added that she started carrying a gun because she felt threatened by Bowers.

While the investigating officer admitted on the stand that Bowers was the initial aggressor on the day she was shot and killed, prosecutors argued that Luther failed to report some of these prior incidents to police. Given that she not pursue the burglary charges that had been filed against Bowers after she broke into Luther’s home, the prosecutors contended that Luther had no reason to think her life was in danger. 

That may not have been a sign that Luther wasn’t concerned or didn’t see Bowers as a threat, though. A few years ago I had a stalker, and it got to the point that I ended up reaching out to law enforcement. While there was enough information to pursue charges, the officer I spoke with warned me that getting police involved can often escalate a stalker’s behavior, and since what this individual had done to date amounted to a couple of misdemeanors that weren’t likely to put them behind bars, I should seriously consider whether or not I wanted to go through with filing a criminal complaint. 

I ultimately decided against it, with the caveat that if things continued to escalate anyway I reserved the right to change my mind. Luther may have had similar concerns about her ex; would filing a police report really stop the abusive behavior, or would it only make things worse? 

Luther’s attorneys argued that it didn’t really matter if their client knew Bowers had a knife in her purse, or that Bowers had threatened to kill her just a few minutes before Luther shot her. Bowers’ past history and troubling behavior gave Luther reason to believe that when Bowers reached into her purse, she was going for a weapon. 

“It turns out she was right,” Fox said. “How many lethal threats have to be pointed at you and plunged into your skin before you have the right to defend yourself and stop your domestic abuser from trying to take your life?”

“This case is sad,” the attorney said. “Domestic violence always is.”

As hard as it might be, the best thing to do when your significant other ends a relationship is to just walk away. It’s downright delusional to think that threats and coercion will convince someone they were wrong to break up. Those actions just prove that they were right to end things… and in this case it cost Taralynn Bowers her life. 

Editor’s Note: Do you appreciate Bearing Arms’s pro-2A reporting that covers defensive gun uses like this one? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth.

Join Bearing Arms VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.