Last week I took a look at the claims by the New York Times that a supposed misquote by Justice Antonin Scalia in the Heller decision has led to a fundamental misunderstanding of our right to keep and bear arms and why the paper’s argument is wildly off-base.
The paper’s reporting was already silly to begin with, but it looks even worse now that one of Scalia’s former law clerks has revealed that a Times reporter reached out to him beforehand, and then ignored virtually everything he had to say. John Bash published a lengthy piece of his own on LinkedIn detailing his discussion with the writer.
The New York Times believes it uncovered a smoking gun in Scalia’s opinion: a single word that, according to the paper and gun control advocates, has distorted Second Amendment jurisprudence for nearly two decades. Scalia’s first citation for the phrase “dangerous and unusual” was Sir William Blackstone (though he also cited 11 other sources). But Blackstone used the phrase “dangerous or unusual,” and the Times thinks that’s a very big difference.
Bash says he “immediately wrote back with a full on-the-record explanation of why there was no misquote,” but says “the article does not refer to my explanation at all and asserts with no qualification that it was a misquote.” Here’s what Bash wrote in his reply to the reporter.
Even if I remembered any conversation with Justice Scalia about this particular point (which I don’t), it would not be ethical for me to share private conversations I had during my clerkship wth Justice Scalia about the substance of opinions.
But just as an appellate lawyer, I don’t see the issue. If the historical sources are mixed on the conjunctive or disjunctive framing, then it is true that there is an historical tradition of prohibiting weapons that are both dangerous and unusual, the narrower category that is encompassed by either framing. The fact that Blackstone is the first citation is just because the treatise citations are in chronological order (consistent with making a point about historical tradition), followed by case citations also in chronological order. The introduction of the treatise list with a “See” signal (rather than no signal) means that the quoted phrase is not necessarily a direct quote from each source (or any source)—as with the “See also” signal for the cases. And assuming that it’s correct that the conjunctive sources all trace back to a single 18th Century treatise, that would not detract from the point that learned commentators had endorsed or applied that test through early American history, which is the point the text is making about historical tradition.
In other words, though Blackstone was the first source cited by Scalia, he wasn’t directly quoting Blackstone at all. That alone should have put an end to the Times’s breathless reporting, but as Bash further explained, “the provenance of the limitation is particularly relevant; the point was that commentators had recognized it throughout history.”
For example, in a Fourth Amendment case, a court might make the point that the curtilage rule—that the immediate vicinity of the home is considered part of the home—has been recognized through American history, citing late Eighteenth Century and Nineteenth Century treatises and cases. Even if that rule could be traced back to a single uncited treatise, that’s not really the point. It’s that courts and commentators endorsed it and so that history and tradition informs the constitutional analysis.
And all that aside, I just think it is implausible that the paragraph would be understood differently if Blackstone had been the second citation rather than the first—especially since Hawkins was himself a very influential legal commentator (if I recall correctly). I’ve never heard of a court or litigant attributing weight to the order of sources subject to the same signal (e.g., “See”), which would seem to me especially unwarranted when the sources are presented chronologically (and so there is an obvious explanation for the ordering other than importance). As I noted before, I think all the sources together make clear a uniform historical tradition of prohibiting dangerous and unusual weapons, the category encompassed by all of their articulations of the rule.
Now, it would be one thing if the Times had included Bash’s explanation alongside the gun control activists who claim that Scalia’s “dangerous and unusual” was ahistorical and has led to an expansion of Second Amendment protections that don’t really exist.
Instead, the paper left out any mention of Bash’s comments, even though its reporter had reached out to Bash before publication to seek out his point of view.
That’s journalistic malpractice, in my opinion. Bash wasn’t some random Second Amendment supporter offering an unsolicited opinion. He clerked for Scalia during the term Heller was decided, worked on the case, and has considerable experience as an appellate attorney. The New York Times apparently thought his perspective was worth seeking out, right up until he offered an explanation that undermined the premise of its story.
When you’re accusing a Supreme Court justice of making a consequential error that has supposedly distorted constitutional law for nearly two decades, you’d better have a convincing answer to someone who can explain why your accusation doesn’t hold water.
The Times didn’t provide one. It didn’t even tell readers that Bash had challenged and refuted its central claim.
It wanted readers to believe it had uncovered a mistake hiding in plain sight for almost twenty years. What it actually demonstrated is how easy it is to manufacture a constitutional controversy when you ignore the evidence that gets in the way of a story promoting restrictions on our right to keep and bear arms.
Editor’s Note: The mainstream media continues to gaslight, spin, and lie about our Second Amendment rights
Help us continue to expose their anti-gun bias by reading news you can trust. Join Bearing Arms VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
Read the full article here
23 Comments
Nice to see insider buying—usually a good signal in this space.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Silver leverage is strong here; beta cuts both ways though.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
The cost guidance is better than expected. If they deliver, the stock could rerate.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Interesting update on NYTimes’s Heller Hit Piece Looks Even Worse After Scalia Clerk Speaks Out – Bearing Arms. Curious how the grades will trend next quarter.
Nice to see insider buying—usually a good signal in this space.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
The cost guidance is better than expected. If they deliver, the stock could rerate.
Uranium names keep pushing higher—supply still tight into 2026.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
The cost guidance is better than expected. If they deliver, the stock could rerate.
Exploration results look promising, but permitting will be the key risk.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
The cost guidance is better than expected. If they deliver, the stock could rerate.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
If AISC keeps dropping, this becomes investable for me.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.