It’s pretty uncommon for a gun owner facing criminal charges to get a sympathetic portrayal from the likes of the New York Times, but Rihanna Kelver got the kid glove treatment from the paper back in August in a piece entitled “A Trans Woman Pulled a Gun and Started a ‘Stand Your Ground’ Debate.”
As the NYTimes noted in its sub-headline, “gun-friendly Wyoming has a ‘stand your ground’” statute that allows people to use force to defend themselves.” So why, the paper asked, was “a trans woman being prosecuted after being shoved to the ground?”
As my colleague Tom Knighton explained shortly after the NYTimes piece was published, the reason was pretty simple. Neither prosecutors nor the judge overseeing Kelver’s criminal case believed that Kelver’s life was in danger when the gun was drawn. Here’s how the NYTimes described what happened:
Ms. Kelver said she did not usually carry her gun in Laramie. She moved there when she was 11, went to high school there, ran for the local school board at 18 and now works at a local bar and grill.
But on Sept. 13, she had felt uneasy after being harassed by an acquaintance, she said, so she tucked her gun onto her hip when she left for a night shift at the Crowbar and Grill, a pizza-and-beer spot where banners for Black Lives Matter and L.G.B.T.Q. rights hang beside the American flag.
Ms. Kelver said she had two shots at the bar, then went outside to smoke a cigarette before her shift at about 10 p.m. One man in a group of three shouted a profanity directed at the Crowbar, according to court records, and Ms. Kelver said that the man, Scott Durham, also yelled an anti-gay slur, though he denied that to the police.
Ms. Kelver, upset, walked up to the men and asked, “What did you just say?” according to police reports. Surveillance video from a downtown camera shows her walking into the street toward the men, one hand on her hip by the pack that held the gun. Seconds later, Mr. Durham pushed her away, and Ms. Kelver stumbled and fell onto her back.
The moment she hit the pavement, she drew and racked the gun and pointed it. She did not fire. The three men walked away, and Ms. Kelver got up and collected her belongings that had scattered in the street. The encounter was over in about 10 seconds.
I agree with Tom’s contention that this was “a simple, basic assault that should have resulted in the cops being called, and probably some community service for the guy, maybe a little jail time.”
But while Tom believed that Kelver was likely going to forfeit the right to keep and bear arms as a result of drawing the pistol, I think he was forgetting how the vast majority of criminal cases end up in this country: with a plea bargain.
Kelver, 28, announced the plea agreement in a Tuesday post to Facebook, but cast it as a pragmatic maneuver rather than an admission of guilt.
“I do maintain three important things,” wrote Kelver, who goes by the name Rihanna Novalee ChasingStars. “I am innocent, I broke no Wyoming statute, and this is not justice.”
Kelver apparently pled no contest to a charge of reckless endangering, and now faces sentencing in early December.
The possibility of 15 years in prison is off the table, and Kelver is likely to receive probation for the offense. According to Cowboy State Daily, if Kelver successfully completes probation, the reckless endangering charge could be completely expunged as well.
Kelver can call this an injustice, but I’d say that this was about as good an outcome as could be expected. Kelver’s Second Amendment rights aren’t forfeit, for one thing, and being spared a decade or more behind bars is no small feat.
I understand that Kelver continues to believe that it was entirely appropriate to draw a gun after being pushed to the ground, but I disagree. There was no reason to believe that any of the three men Kelver confronted had any intent to do harm, and according to the New York Times, Kelver was pushed away by one man after getting too close, not pushed to the ground.
I’m sure it’s not easy being a transgender person in Laramie, Wyoming, but that doesn’t mean you get to draw down on someone who pushes you when you get in their face after hearing a slur directed your way. It may very well be the case that no one involved in the incident acted with angelic intent, but crass behavior or even a simple assault doesn’t automatically result in a reasonable belief that your life is in danger.
Self-defense is a human right, and Rihanna Kelver’s continued ability to carry a firearm for personal protection is a positive outcome as far as I’m concerned. But when you’re carrying a gun for self-defense, you’re also shouldering the responsibility to recognize the difference between an unpleasant confrontation and a genuine threat of death or serious bodily harm.
Insults, intimidation, and even a shove don’t automatically justify pointing a gun at someone. Based on the police reports and surveillance footage, Kelver made a serious mistake that night.
Fortunately, the plea agreement offers Kelver an opportunity to move forward without spending years behind bars or forfeiting Second Amendment rights. Hopefully, the experience will also serve as a valuable lesson. A bruised ego or an offensive remark isn’t worth a felony conviction, much less a potentially deadly confrontation. I hope that Kelver truly understands that the best outcome for an armed citizen isn’t winning a legal argument about the justified use of force, but getting home safely without ever having to draw a gun to begin with.
Editor’s Note: The radical Left will stop at nothing to enact their extreme gun control agenda and strip us of our Second Amendment rights.
Help us continue to report on and expose the Democrats’ gun-grabbing schemes. Join Bearing Arms VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
Read the full article here
27 Comments
Exploration results look promising, but permitting will be the key risk.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Interesting update on Wyoming Gun Owner Avoids Felony Conviction in Controversial Self-Defense Case – Bearing Arms. Curious how the grades will trend next quarter.
Production mix shifting toward USA might help margins if metals stay firm.
Nice to see insider buying—usually a good signal in this space.
Production mix shifting toward USA might help margins if metals stay firm.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Interesting update on Wyoming Gun Owner Avoids Felony Conviction in Controversial Self-Defense Case – Bearing Arms. Curious how the grades will trend next quarter.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
The cost guidance is better than expected. If they deliver, the stock could rerate.
Uranium names keep pushing higher—supply still tight into 2026.
Production mix shifting toward USA might help margins if metals stay firm.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
If AISC keeps dropping, this becomes investable for me.
Production mix shifting toward USA might help margins if metals stay firm.
Interesting update on Wyoming Gun Owner Avoids Felony Conviction in Controversial Self-Defense Case – Bearing Arms. Curious how the grades will trend next quarter.
Interesting update on Wyoming Gun Owner Avoids Felony Conviction in Controversial Self-Defense Case – Bearing Arms. Curious how the grades will trend next quarter.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Nice to see insider buying—usually a good signal in this space.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Interesting update on Wyoming Gun Owner Avoids Felony Conviction in Controversial Self-Defense Case – Bearing Arms. Curious how the grades will trend next quarter.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
Good point. Watching costs and grades closely.
If AISC keeps dropping, this becomes investable for me.